Which is the best 7-seater? We test Land Rover Discovery S & Kia Sorento 4

21

LET’S start this twin test with a question.

Do you want a car that: A) looks nice on your drive, or B) is nicer to drive?

Which is the best 7-seater - we test the Land Rover Discovery S and Kia's Sorento 4

8

Which is the best 7-seater – we test the Land Rover Discovery S and Kia’s Sorento 4Credit: simon thompson

“A” is obviously the Land Rover Discovery, the middle-class yoga mummy wagon that can exit a wet polo field with ease.

But it’s expensive and has a wonky rear end

Or do you put your sensible hat on and go “B”, the Kia Sorento?

Also seven seats, absolutely loaded with kit and powered by a future-proof petrol/electric plug-in hybrid engine.

You might think I’m daft pitching these two head-to-head, as the Disco is clearly bigger.

The Land Rover Discovery is the middle-class yoga mummy wagon that can exit a wet polo field with ease

8

The Land Rover Discovery is the middle-class yoga mummy wagon that can exit a wet polo field with easeCredit: simon thompson

But they do the same job and price-wise they’re almost identical.

This all-singing Sorento tops out at £53,095, whereas the base Disco (250hp) starts at £53,695.

First up, then, Disco.

She’s a big girl.

Not easy to park at Tesco, let alone dodge the hungry concrete walls at a multi-storey.

The Land Rover is expensive and has a wonky rear end

8

The Land Rover is expensive and has a wonky rear endCredit: simon thompson

But life is a breeze on the open road.

Standard air suspension makes every trip smooth and relaxing, while the new mild-hybrid six-cylinder diesel has plenty of oomph.

Note. There aren’t any plug-in hybrids yet, so this is as electrified as Disco gets for now.

My testing returned 31mpg, which is about £110 to fill up

At this point I should also spell out that Disco has seven full-size seats.

Standard air suspension makes every trip smooth and relaxing, while the new mild-hybrid six-cylinder diesel has plenty of oomph

8

Standard air suspension makes every trip smooth and relaxing, while the new mild-hybrid six-cylinder diesel has plenty of oomphCredit: simon thompson

A gangly teen could happily sit in row three.

It’s a bit tight climbing on board but once you’re in, you’re in.

Other positives.

The new Pivi Pro infotainment system is crisp, responsive and talks to your phone.

There are more USB ports than seats.

Key facts: Land Rover Discovery S

Price: £56,480

Engine: 3-litre 6cyl turbo diesel mild hybrid

Power: 300hp, 650Nm

0-60mph: 6.5 secs

Top speed: 130mph

Economy: 31mpg

EV range: Hasn’t got one

CO2: 218g/km

Negatives?

Boot space is laughable with all seven seats up.

Now we come to the Kia.

As I said earlier, a smaller car but less intimidating to drive and park.

It won’t beat a Disco in a tug of war but Sorento is all-wheel drive and winter proof on the right tyres.

The Sorento's cabin is a big win and includes features that are all pricey add-ons over at Land Rover

8

The Sorento’s cabin is a big win and includes features that are all pricey add-ons over at Land RoverCredit: simon thompson

The big win is the cabin.

Big glass roof, window blinds, heated front seats, heated steering wheel, heated middle-row seats that electronically tilt and slide, head-up display, wireless phone charging, fancy sound system.

All these goodies are pricey add-ons over at Land Rover.

Plus, Sorento takes driver assistance tech to the next level. Indicate to turn left or right and a blind-spot camera feed pops up in the driver’s binnacle.

Not even Volvo has that.

Sorento takes driver assistance tech to the next level. Indicate to turn left or right and a blind-spot camera feed pops up in the driver’s binnacle

8

Sorento takes driver assistance tech to the next level. Indicate to turn left or right and a blind-spot camera feed pops up in the driver’s binnacleCredit: simon thompson

Row three is a little squished for tall adults but the middle row and boot are roomier than the Disco — which is impressive when you consider the electric gubbins in most hybrids eat into rear space.

Now we come to another big selling-point of this car: Diesel-like fuel economy without being a diesel and up to 35 miles of pure-electric driving.

I shuttled around my neighbourhood for two days without waking the engine and averaged 43mpg over two weeks.

That’s good for any car, let alone a two-ton SUV.

I’ve said it before but Kia knows how to read the room.

The Sorento mild hybrid starts at £39k with the diesel from £41k

8

The Sorento mild hybrid starts at £39k with the diesel from £41kCredit: simon thompson

It sells well-engineered and well-specced cars at reasonable prices.

The Sorento mild hybrid starts at £39k. Diesel from £41k.

So, to go back to the start: Which would I choose? A or B?

Disco has the badge and that mountain goat ability should you ever fancy an extreme picnic

And it’s a diesel, so it’s better for towing.

Sorento has all the kit, the EV drive mode and that seven-year warranty.

Easy decision.

The Kia has diesel-like fuel economy without being a diesel and can do up to 35 miles of pure-electric driving

8

The Kia has diesel-like fuel economy without being a diesel and can do up to 35 miles of pure-electric drivingCredit: simon thompson

I like value, not vanity.

And I haven’t got a caravan.

Sorento it is.

Key facts: Kia Sorento 4

Price: £53,095

Engine: 1.6-litre turbo petrol plug-in hybrid

Power: 261bhp, 350Nm

0-60mph: 8.4 secs

Top speed: 119mph

Economy: 43mpg

EV range: 35 miles

CO2: 38g/km

Land Rover’s new Discovery Sport has had a nip/tuck since it first arrived in 2014

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More